← All Field NotesTariff Risk Management Lives in the Contract: Who Pays When the Legal Basis Changes

Field Notes

Tariff Risk Management Lives in the Contract: Who Pays When the Legal Basis Changes

Share via Email

TL;DR: When the Supreme Court struck down the IEEPA tariffs in February 2026, the refunds went to whoever was named as importer of record on each customs entry, not to whoever bore the cost through higher prices. Customs law stops there, so tariff risk management for manufacturers now depends on contract clauses that say who pays a duty, who keeps a refund, and what happens when the statute behind a tariff changes.

Key takeaways:

  • The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 on 20 February 2026, in Learning Resources v. Trump, that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs, and it left refunds to the lower courts.
  • Only the importer of record, or the broker that filed the entry, can claim an IEEPA refund through CBP's CAPE system, which opened on 20 April 2026.
  • Kelley Drye advised in March 2026 that US customs law sets no general obligation for an importer to pass a refund on to its customers, so the contract decides.
  • Within five months of the ruling, the legal basis for the replacement tariff changed twice: a Section 122 surcharge from 24 February, then Section 301 tariffs on 60 economies from 24 July.

Costco, Lululemon, FedEx and UPS were all sued by their own customers within weeks of the Supreme Court's tariff ruling.[^1] The suits allege that the companies passed IEEPA duties on in their prices and now stand to collect the refunds themselves, and they rely on unjust enrichment and breach of contract.[^1][^2] The same question sits inside ordinary supply contracts between manufacturers and their suppliers.

The Supreme Court held 6-3 on 20 February 2026 that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs, and did not rule on how refunds should be paid.
The Supreme Court held 6-3 on 20 February 2026 that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs, and did not rule on how refunds should be paid.

The Refund Went to the Importer of Record

The court did not say who should be repaid. It held that IEEPA "does not authorize the President to impose tariffs" and left the rest to the Court of International Trade.[^3][^4] CBP's answer was administrative. Its CAPE refund system, launched in ACE on 20 April 2026, accepts claims only from importers of record or the brokers that filed their entries.[^5][^6]

  • The money. About 166 billion dollars was collected under IEEPA, and the government said in a filing of 2 October that more than 75 percent had been refunded with interest.[^7][^8] By 17 September CBP had accepted about 134.7 billion dollars in declarations and certified about 122 billion dollars to the Treasury.[^9]
  • Who can claim. "Only one party can file an IEEPA tariff refund claim for each entry," Ayar Law wrote in April: the importer of record, "not the company that paid for the goods."[^6] SPS Commerce says the business that bore the cost through a higher unit price "is often not the one CBP is paying back."[^10]
  • No duty to share. Kelley Drye found "no general obligation under U.S. customs law" for importers to distribute refunds, and said the answer "will depend on the contractual arrangement between the parties."[^2] Jones Walker, writing for downstream buyers, noted that an importer can receive a cash refund "for costs it already recovered from its customers."[^11]
  • The unfinished part. Refunds on finally liquidated entries of importers that never sued are still contested. The government has appealed the trade court's universal refund orders, and the importer class certified on 8 October has no relief order yet.[^7][^12]

So the government has mostly paid. What it paid, and to whom, follows the customs entry, and the customs entry often does not reflect the commercial deal.

By 17 September 2026 CBP had accepted about 134.7 billion dollars in IEEPA refund declarations and certified about 122 billion dollars, with interest, to the Treasury for payment to importers of record.
By 17 September 2026 CBP had accepted about 134.7 billion dollars in IEEPA refund declarations and certified about 122 billion dollars, with interest, to the Treasury for payment to importers of record.

Trade Compliance and the Contract Answer Different Questions

A customs entry settles who owes the duty to the government. A supply contract settles who carries that cost between the parties and what happens to it later. Trade compliance teams usually own the first answer and commercial teams the second, and the two do not always agree. SPS Commerce notes that a vendor agreement can use DDP language "while the actual customs entry names a different party as importer of record."[^10]

The Thomson Reuters Institute wrote in March that pass-through clauses, price adjustments and indemnities "will determine which parties actually gets the money."[^13] Five provisions in a manufacturing contract are worth checking first.

  1. Incoterms and the named importer. Under DDP the seller carries duties, and under the other ten Incoterms the buyer does.[^10] The refund follows the name on the entry, so check that the contract and the entry agree.
  2. Pass-through and true-up. A clause that passes a tariff on should also say what happens when the tariff is reversed. Corporate Compliance Insights advised firms to work out "who is entitled to a refund if duties previously passed through to a customer are later recovered."[^14]
  3. Change in law. Ask whether the clause covers a tariff that is ruled unlawful and then replaced under another statute at a different rate, because that is what happened in 2026.
  4. Force majeure. Foley's view is that force majeure "typically does not allow for price increases" and that a surcharge on a fixed-price contract "is a breach of the agreement." Under the UCC, increased cost alone does not excuse performance.[^15]
  5. Refund ownership. The cleanest fix is one line saying who keeps any recovered duty, and on what timetable, once the importer has actually been paid.[^11][^14]
Section 301 tariffs of 10 or 12.5 percent on 60 economies took effect on 24 July 2026, the day the Section 122 surcharge that followed the IEEPA ruling expired.
Section 301 tariffs of 10 or 12.5 percent on 60 economies took effect on 24 July 2026, the day the Section 122 surcharge that followed the IEEPA ruling expired.

Tariff Risk Management Clauses for the Next Change of Basis

What the record shows: the replacement regime has already moved twice. A Section 122 surcharge of 10 percent took effect on 24 February, for a statutory maximum of 150 days.1 The trade court held it unlawful on 7 May, limited relief to the plaintiffs, and the ruling has since been stayed pending appeal.23 The surcharge lapsed on 24 July, the same day Section 301 tariffs of 10 or 12.5 percent on 60 economies took effect.45 Those duties are under challenge too. The trade court heard argument on 30 September and had not ruled by 12 October.3 Separately, Section 232 duties on steel and aluminum have applied to full value since 6 April.67

What we infer: a manufacturer pricing 2027 contracts should assume at least one more change of legal basis during the term. Each change raises the question IEEPA raised: is the duty refundable, and to whom? Customer litigation is already testing the answer. Carter Ledyard expected business-to-business claims to follow the consumer and shipper cases, and said their viability would "depend heavily on the particular facts and contract language."8

What we recommend: run Foley's third check across the top suppliers and the top customers. It asks whether contracts address "tariff-related cost increases, price adjustment rights, delivery obligations" and renegotiation.9 Then add the refund question, which the check leaves out. Our note on planning for the round covers the geopolitical risk in the next tariff announcement. A contract review is slower work, and it pays off when a court changes the rate instead of the White House. The same clause discipline for controlled products is in our note on classification drift, and the sector view is on the manufacturing sector page.

Fortius Intel note: A tariff clause that only covers new duties is half a clause. The 2026 refunds showed that a reversal moves money too, and a contract that is silent on it leaves the outcome to whoever is named on the customs entry. If the Section 301 tariffs fall at the trade court, the same thing happens again for every duty paid since 24 July.

Methodology: this note draws on the Supreme Court decision as summarised by Thomson Reuters and Husch Blackwell; CBP refund data reported by C.H. Robinson and Davis Wright Tremaine; law firm analysis from Kelley Drye, Jones Walker, Carter Ledyard, Foley and Lardner, Troutman, Snell and Wilmer, Dorsey, Holland and Knight, Miller Nash, Diaz Trade Law, Ayar Law and Reed Smith; and commentary from the Thomson Reuters Institute, Corporate Compliance Insights, UHY and SPS Commerce. Each figure was checked against a second independent source where one exists. This is not legal advice.


Footnotes

  1. Snell and Wilmer, "Tariffs Redux: What Importers Should Know About IEEPA Refunds and Section 122," 24 February 2026, https://www.swlaw.com/publication/tariffs-redux-what-importers-should-know-about-ieepa-refunds-and-section-122/ (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: the 10 percent Section 122 surcharge effective 24 February 2026 and its 150-day statutory limit. Cross-check: Troutman, 12 October 2026. ↩

  2. Davis Wright Tremaine, "Trade court invalidating Section 122 tariff," 13 May 2026, https://www.dwt.com/insights/2026/05/trade-court-invalidating-section-122-tariff (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: the Court of International Trade holding the Section 122 tariff unlawful on 7 May 2026, by 2-1, with relief limited to the plaintiffs. ↩

  3. Troutman Pepper Locke, "Getting Duties Back: Where Recovery Stands Under IEEPA, Section 122 and Section 301 Forced Labor Tariffs," 12 October 2026, https://www.troutman.com/insights/getting-duties-back-where-recovery-stands-under-ieepa-section-122-and-section-301-forced-labor-tariffs/ (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: the stay pending appeal of the Section 122 ruling; argument in the Section 301 forced labor cases on 30 September 2026 with no decision as of 12 October; cross-check of the Section 122 timeline. ↩ ↩2

  4. Dorsey and Whitney, "Announced Section 301 tariffs," client alert, 24 July 2026, https://www.dorsey.com/newsresources/publications/client-alerts/2026/7/announced-section-301-tariffs (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: Section 301 tariffs of 10 or 12.5 percent on 60 economies effective 24 July 2026. ↩

  5. UHY, "Tariff reset: Section 122 expires as Section 301 duties expand," 24 July 2026, https://uhy-us.com/insights/news/2026/july/tariff-reset-section-122-expires-as-section-301-duties-expand (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: cross-check that Section 122 expired on 24 July 2026 as the Section 301 duties took effect. ↩

  6. Reed Smith, "Trump 2.0 tariff tracker," 3 November 2026, https://tradecomplianceresourcehub.com/2026/11/03/trump-2-0-tariff-tracker (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: CBP's launch of CAPE in ACE on 20 April 2026, limited to importers of record or the brokers that filed the entries; the Section 232 metals overhaul effective 6 April 2026 with duties on full value. ↩

  7. Miller Nash, "Tariffs in flux: IEEPA and Section 122 struck down, Section 232 duties expand," 8 July 2026, https://www.millernash.com/firm-news/news/tariffs-in-flux-ieepa-and-section-122-struck-down-section-232-duties-expand (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: cross-check of the Section 232 metals overhaul effective 6 April 2026 and duties on full value. ↩

  8. Carter Ledyard and Milburn, "Tariff Refunds and Pass-Through Litigation: Where We Are Now and What Comes Next," 14 April 2026, https://www.clm.com/tariff-refunds-and-pass-through-litigation-where-we-are-now-and-what-comes-next/ (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: class actions filed against FedEx and UPS (20 February 2026), EssilorLuxottica, Costco and Lululemon; unjust enrichment, breach of contract and consumer protection theories; business-to-business claims expected, with viability depending "heavily on the particular facts and contract language." These are allegations, not findings. ↩

  9. Foley and Lardner, "Five Checks for Preparing Manufacturers for Tariff Volatility," 3 September 2026, https://www.foley.com/insights/publications/2026/09/five-checks-for-preparing-manufacturers-for-tariff-volatility/ (retrieved 6 November 2026). Source for: the third check, asking whether contracts address "tariff-related cost increases, price adjustment rights, delivery obligations" and renegotiation or termination; the absence of any reference to refunds or the importer of record. ↩

Run Free Scan

About the author

Shekhar Attri, Co-Founder & CTO. An Indian Army Special Forces veteran with 21 years of service and a gallantry medal, Shekhar's corporate security advisory work spans Singapore, India, the Philippines, and the UAE, alongside PhD research on machine intelligence under incomplete information.