TL;DR: A crisis almost always moves the share price, but the size of the first drop says little about where the stock ends up. Evidence from corporate crises and from the 2022 Russia exits points the same way: investors reward a response that settles the uncertainty, even when settling it costs money.
Key takeaways:
- SenateSHJ's 2024 review of 70 high-profile crises at listed companies found that 80 percent saw their share price fall, by an average of 12 percent, and that recovery took 60 days on average.
- Crises involving casualties averaged a 24.4 percent drop and environmental crises 23.4 percent, roughly double the overall average.
- Marsh and Cranfield University followed 23 listed companies through high-profile incidents for 250 trading days and named the strength of leadership's response as the most important mark of a company that came out ahead.
- Societe Generale agreed on 11 April 2022 to sell its Russian bank at a cost of 3.1 billion euros, and its shares rose more than 6 percent in early trading.
On 11 April 2022, Societe Generale agreed to sell Rosbank to Interros Capital, the company linked to Vladimir Potanin, and said the exit would cost it 3.1 billion euros.[^1][^2] Its shares were up more than 6 percent in early trading, and Reuters reported a rise of as much as 8 percent.[^2][^3] A bank had announced a multibillion euro loss caused by a war it did not start, and the market treated the news as good.

The Numbers Behind Share Price Recovery
The most recent large dataset comes from a communications consultancy, so read it as a practitioner study, not peer-reviewed research. SenateSHJ's Crisis Value Erosion Index, released in May 2024, examined 70 high-profile crises at listed companies over four decades.[^4][^5]
- How often prices fall. 80 percent of the companies examined saw a drop in share price during the crisis.[^4][^6]
- How far. The average drop was 12 percent. Crises involving casualties averaged 24.4 percent and environmental crises 23.4 percent.[^4][^5]
- How long. Shares took an average of 60 days to recover. For some companies recovery took years, and some never recovered.[^4][^5]
- The outlier. BP lost about 50 percent of its value after the Deepwater Horizon disaster.[^4][^5]
The averages hide the spread, and the spread is the useful part. Marsh's 2018 study with Cranfield University followed 23 listed companies through high-profile incidents over a 250 trading-day window and separated those that merely survived from those that thrived.[^7][^8] It concluded that "the strength of a leadership's response to a crisis appears to be the single most important hallmark of a thriving company." It also pointed to transparent management, financial reserves and risk transfer, supply chain agility, and preparation such as stress testing and simulation exercises.[^7]
What the record shows: the first drop is close to universal, and the eventual loss varies with the type of event and the quality of the response. What we infer: the event type sets the floor of the damage, and the response decides how much of it becomes permanent. Neither study isolates response quality cleanly from everything else, so treat this as a consistent pattern rather than a measured effect.

Geopolitical Shocks Test a Different Judgement
Most crisis studies cover events a company caused or could have prevented, such as fraud or a fatal accident. A geopolitical shock works differently. A war, a sanctions package or an export ban lands on many companies at once, and the market does not ask who is to blame. It asks how exposed each company is and how quickly management will decide what to do about it.
The Russia exits of 2022 are the largest test of that question so far. Jeffrey Sonnenfeld's team at the Yale School of Management graded roughly 600 publicly traded companies from A, for full withdrawal, to F, for business as usual, and compared their returns.[^9][^10] Between 23 February and 8 April 2022, companies graded A outperformed those graded F, and companies that refused to withdraw fell further than the broader market.[^9][^11]
The work carries real caveats. The authors assigned the grades themselves, the measurement windows ran only a few weeks, and the posting on the Harvard Law School Forum reported a modest effect for each step in grade.[^10] The same authors produced both publications, so they are not independent confirmation of each other. What we infer: the market rewarded the decision more than it punished the exposure. A company that named its loss, put a number on it and left removed an open-ended question from its valuation. Societe Generale's April 2022 reaction fits that reading. It is one case, and it does not prove the rule.
The reverse case is the company that stays without saying for how long or at what cost. Its exposure does not shrink, and each new sanctions package reopens the question of what the business is worth. What we infer: the discount investors apply in that case is for an undecided outcome, and it can outlast the event that caused it.
That is the practical difference between an ordinary crisis and a geopolitical one. In the second case the share price is reacting to an unresolved decision, and the company controls how long that decision stays unresolved.

Four Things to Settle Before the Next Shock
The crisis plan most companies hold was written for an incident such as a fire or a data breach. It covers who speaks and who calls the regulator. It rarely covers the decision a geopolitical shock forces, which is whether to stay in a market, shrink there or leave, and at what cost. What we recommend:
- Pre-price the exit. For each market where a sanctions or conflict event is plausible, estimate the write-down an exit would cause and refresh it each quarter. A figure prepared in advance can be announced in days rather than weeks.
- Name the decision owner. Decide now who can approve a market exit, and with whose sign-off. The Yale grading measured returns over the first weeks of the war, and a decision that waits for the next scheduled board meeting is slow by that standard.1
- Separate exposure from decision in investor messages. Investors usually know the exposure from your filings. What they lack in the first days is the decision and its cost. One line with the expected charge and the timetable tells them more than a page of context. Our note on disclosure to investors, lenders and customers covers the timing for each audience.
- Watch the markets that move first. Insurance, currency and credit pricing often reacts before equities, as our note on which prices move first sets out. Those signals can buy a few days for the decision.
Treat geopolitical risk in the crisis plan as a capital allocation question with a deadline, and test the plan against one named market each year. For a review built on your own market exposures, see our brief.
Fortius Intel note: If your company had to announce a market exit next week, could finance put a defensible loss figure on it within 72 hours? If not, run that exercise before the next sanctions package lands.
Methodology: this note draws on SenateSHJ's 2024 Crisis Value Erosion Index as reported by Medianet, Mi3 and the Crisis Response Journal, Marsh's 2018 study with Cranfield University, the Yale School of Management work on Russia exits as published by Yale Insights and the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance with coverage in The Hill, and contemporaneous Reuters, Financial Times and Investing.com reporting on Societe Generale's Rosbank sale. The SenateSHJ figures were read through secondary coverage, not the full report. We could not retrieve the Control Risks article on crisis recovery named in our topic brief, and nothing here relies on it. This is not investment advice.
Footnotes
-
Yale Insights, Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, Steven Tian and Steven Zaslavsky, "Businesses Staying in Russia Are Underperforming the Market," 28 April 2022, https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/businesses-staying-in-russia-are-underperforming-the-market (retrieved 10 November 2026). Source for: about 600 publicly traded companies; the A to F grading by level of curtailment; the 23 February to 8 April 2022 window; companies refusing to withdraw falling further than the broader market. ↩
About the author
Jay Bimbrah, Co-Founder & COO. A former Scotland Yard counter-terrorism investigator, Jay has advised EMEA tier-1 banks and Lloyd's market firms on distinguishing real exposure from theoretical risk.
